View Count: 161 |  Publish Date: July 29, 2013
Inquirer Editorial: Unions want to call the shots
Posted: Sunday, July 28, 2013, 1:09 AM
If the political drama being played out in Philadelphia today seems familiar, thats because it should. Some are trying to bring back the days when mayors who were in bed with union bosses signed expensive employee contracts that almost put this town in bankruptcy.
That stopped 21 years ago, when Mayor Ed Rendell used his powers effectively to get contracts that froze salaries and cut benefits to a level the city could afford. There is not the same fear of bankruptcy now, but Mayor Nutter continues the fight over union contracts.
Among those Nutter is fighting, ironically, are fellow politicians with mayoral ambitions. But if their willingness to appease unions at any cost is an indication of the way they would run the city, they are the last people Philadelphians should elect chief executive.
Rather than preserve the powers that helped Rendell, City Councilman Jim Kenney and City Controller Alan Butkovitz are proposing to emasculate the mayors office. They want to take away a mayors ability to challenge a contract arbitration decision in court unless he gets City Council approval. More coverageWhich city officials will keep pay raises?
Its a terrible idea. Involving Council would only inject more politics into the process. It would return Philadelphia to the Rizzo era, when arbitration rulings were rarely challenged and unions got the sweetheart deals that put the city in the poorhouse. Anyone who backs this lame notion is unqualified to be mayor.
That the proposal is a result of political calculation is evident in its being pushed by electricians union boss John Dougherty. His Local 98 represents not a single municipal employee, but it does have buckets of campaign cash to entice mayoral aspirants looking for a sugar daddy.
Kenney, the son of a fireman, says he wants to help firefighters, who havent had a contract for four years. Butkovitz says Nutter has made a mockery of the concept of binding arbitration by challenging rulings. Rep. Bob Brady (D., Pa.) said of union members, Its these people who run this city.
Workers who havent had a raise in years should be frustrated. But public officials are elected to put taxpayers first, not the employees who work for taxpayers. Elected officials cant forget that and let their political desires return this city to an era of irresponsible spending.
It would have been better if Nutter had settled the dispute without multiple court challenges. Now, with that contract still unsettled, negotiations on a new one have begun. Meanwhile, the mayors inability to effectively explain to the public why he is fighting the arbitration award has allowed foes to depict him as uncaring toward poor public servants who just want to be treated fairly.
The prevailing impression is that pay raises are at the heart of Nutters beef with firefighters, but health insurance is the bigger problem. In 2009, the police union agreed to a less expensive self-insurance fund. But the firefighters want to keep their Cadillac plan, under which they pay no premiums and co-pays of only $5 for doctor visits and $2 for generic drugs.
The firefighters plan costs taxpayers $1,270 a month for each of the departments 2,000 union members. Under the arbitrators ruling, that tab would grow to $1,620 per month per member. For the police unions self-insurance plan, meanwhile, the city pays about $1,150 per month per member. Thats because instead of a lump sum, the city pays only on actual claims.
Arbitrators may be persuaded by arguments that the city can afford to give employees what they want. But a mayor must look beyond what a city can afford now to whats best for taxpayers in the long term, including an ability to redirect revenue from employee health insurance to other needs, such as schools.
Kenneys proposal would hamper a mayors ability to act in the best interests of taxpayers. Council President Darrell Clarke, who some fear has let his mayoral dreams tie him too closely to Doughertys political apparatus, can prove otherwise by letting proponents of this bad idea know he will fight it. #post2 .pw-icon.ra1-pw-icon-reddit {background: url() 0px 0px no-repeat !important;width: 60px !important;height: 20px !important;margin-right:8px;}#post2 .pw-icon.ra1-pw-icon-email {background: url() 0px 0px no-repeat !important;width: 71px !important;height: 28px !important;}135comments

 ability   arbitration   city   contract   council   employee   fight   firefighters   icon   important   insurance   mayor   mayors   member   Nutter   political   put   taxpayers   Union   want 

Picture Keywords
 ability   arbitration   city   contract   council   employee   fight   firefighters   icon   important   insurance   mayor   mayors   member   Nutter   political   put   taxpayers   Union   want 
Time: 2:30  |  News Code: 320246  |  Site:
Collecting News by Parset Crawler
Know more about Parset crawler