News
View Count: 156 |  Publish Date: April 06, 2014
What do college athletes, FedEx drivers, and strippers have in common?
Jane M. Von Bergen, Inquirer Staff WriterPosted: Sunday, April 6, 2014, 1:10 AM
What do exotic dancers, Sleepys mattress delivery men, graduate assistants, FedEx drivers, cleaning contractors, student interns, carpenters, and college football players have in common?
They are all struggling, in some legal way, to determine whether they are employees or something else all together.
Is the exotic dancer actually an independent contractor, running her own tip-generating business and leasing pole space from an adult entertainment bar? Or is she an employee, working assigned hours and wearing (or not wearing) what she is told?
Are Sleepys drivers independent contractors who own their trucks and get paid by the delivery, or are they more like employees, because they have to wear a Sleepys uniform, follow a Sleepys schedule, and allow the company to attach a logo to their trucks? More coverageD.C. battle lines drawn on Comcast deal
What about Division I college football players on scholarships? Are Temple Universitys players, for example, actually employees at the school?
The National Labor Relations Boards regional director in Chicago made headlines last month when he determined that Northwestern Universitys college football players are not simply students on athletic scholarships. They are, Peter Sung Ohr ruled, employees, and, therefore, entitled to unionize.
Saying that players, under tight control by their coaches, spend more time practicing, training, traveling to away games, and generating revenue for their school than they do hitting the books, Ohr decided that the players were employees.
Its tapping into a broader issue of what defines work for an employer and employee, said Lonnie Golden, a professor of economics and labor at Pennsylvania State University in Abington.
Two categories
The examples fall into two broad categories.
One, generating an avalanche of lawsuits, focuses on misclassification - employees are misclassified as independent contractors.
Companies dont have to contribute to unemployment or workers compensation funds for independent contractors. No overtime either.
Even so, sometimes independent-contract status helps workers, providing flexibility and perhaps a higher hourly rate. In the Sleepys case, some drivers registered their businesses with the state.
But it is illegal to call someone an independent contractor when that person is acting like an employee, with the company exercising control over most work activities. The U.S. Labor Department has said it will crack down on misclassification cases.
There have been cases involving carpenters and cleaning contractors. Nationally, there are more than 20 pending cases involving FedEx drivers.
There are a couple of different layers, said Anthony L. Marchetti Jr., a Cherry Hill lawyer who represented the Sleepys drivers before the New Jersey Supreme Court in March.
Its hard to find good work that will support a family, he said. Someone who is out of work will do whatever is necessary to get a paycheck. They are willing to waive the protections of the laws.
The companies have seized on this.
Former Sleepys driver Sam Hargrove, 48, of Willingboro, listed his business with the state. But, he said, there was nothing independent about it. Its about control.
Misclassification is one category; the other is whether an individual is primarily a student, or primarily an employee.
Decisions ahead
Besides the latest case involving the football players, other cases in this category have been brought by unpaid student interns and by graduate students who receive scholarships and stipends and must teach undergrad classes.
Case law has gone both ways on the graduate student issue.
But a ruling by the Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board in 2001 determined that Temples teaching graduate students were also Temple employees. The students, now numbering close to 800, formed the Temple University Graduate Students Association.
The union just finished negotiating its recent contract. The vote is Monday.
Were doing work for the university that is making them money and has nothing to do with what were doing as students, said shop steward Matt Unangst, 28, now pursuing a Ph.D. in history.
Unpaid interns have filed lawsuits claiming their on-the-job tasks do not further their education and simply amount to work without wages.
PBS talk-show host Charlie Rose agreed to pay $110,000 in July 2013 to settle a lawsuit by unpaid interns on his show.
The next step for Northwesterns administration occurs Wednesday, the deadline for the university to ask NLRB officials in Washington to review the Chicago directors decision.
Northwestern believes the decision overlooked or completely ignored much of the critical testimony supporting the universitys position that student-athletes are not employees, the university said in a statement.
On April 25, Wildcats football players can vote on whether to join the College Athletes Players Association union. The ballots will be impounded until the NLRB in Washington decides whether to consider the case, or until it reaches its decision.
Owls opinion
The players bid to be unionized is a big deal in employment law, with implications for universities and their athletic programs. But not to Temples football players, now in spring workouts.
Im not familiar with the whole thing going on in Washington, said Owls defensive back Alex Wells, 19. Im not even up on whats going on with March Madness.
Offensive lineman Kyle Friend, 20, a business major, said he only heard about it after a professor asked for his opinion.
I dont think of myself as an employee, he said.
Their coach, Matt Rhule, said he doesnt see his players as employees. But, he said, hes pro-union. Anything that gives the players a voice, I think thats a good thing.
jvonbergen@phillynews.com
215-854-2769
@JaneVonBergen
www.inquirer.com/jobbing
Previous Story:Samsung adding anti-theft solutions to smartphonesNext Story: Senate hearing on Comcast merger comes amid major concerns Jane M. Von BergenInquirer Staff Writer #post2 .pw-icon.ra1-pw-icon-reddit {background: url() 0px 0px no-repeat !important;width: 60px !important;height: 20px !important;margin-right:8px;}#post2 .pw-icon.ra1-pw-icon-email {background: url() 0px 0px no-repeat !important;width: 71px !important;height: 28px !important;}0 commentsReprints & Permissions »

Time: 12:48  |  News Code: 396121  |  Site: philly.com
Collecting News by Parset Crawler
Know more about Parset crawler